Close Menu
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    FlurrySports
    • Home
    • Betting
      • Super Bowl Odds
      • NFL Picks
    • Fantasy Football
      • Fantasy Football Articles
      • Fantasy Football Rankings
      • DFS
    • NFL
      • NFL Stats
    • UFC
    • NBA
    • NCAA
      • College Football
      • College Basketball
    • More
      • NASCAR
      • WWE
      • Golf
      • MLB
      • NHL
      • Soccer
      • Combat Sports
      • Esports
      • Olympics
      • Fantasy Basketball
    • Shop
    • Contact Us
    FlurrySports
    You are at:Home»MLB»New York Yankees All-Time Baseball Team

    New York Yankees All-Time Baseball Team

    Luke ReimerBy Luke ReimerMarch 24, 2021No Comments3 Mins Read MLB
    Building the greatest all-time New York Yankees team and lineup with the best players in the franchise's history.
    Credit: Greg Fiume/Getty Images
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email Reddit WhatsApp

    The New York Yankees are the most storied team in MLB history. They always seek to have a stacked team. The Yankees have gone down in history, featuring players like Babe Ruth, Mickey Mantle, Joe DiMaggio and Yogi Berra. With so much history on one franchise, it should be fun to take a look at the greatest players in New York’s history by creating an all-time Yankees team.

    The format of an all-time MLB team consists of one player in all eight fielding positions, as well as four starting pitchers and one reliever. The teams were created using players who were the most skilled, the most influential and the most popular in that team’s history. Players were only selected for one team, so you won’t see Alex Rodriguez on the Seattle Mariners and New York Yankees; he will be on one of the other.

    Building the greatest all-time New York Yankees team and lineup with the best players in the franchise's history.
    Credit: Greg Fiume/Getty Images

    New York Yankees History

    The New York Yankees started their history off as the Baltimore Orioles. In 1903, the team relocated to New York and took the name “New York Highlanders.” In 1913, the Highlanders changed their name to the team we know now as the Yankees. The Yankees have won 40 AL pennants and 27 World Series titles. Their most recent playoff appearance was in 2020.

    All-Time New York Yankees Team

    PositionPlayerYankees YearsYankees StatsYankees Awards
    Starting PitcherWhitey Ford1950, 1953-1967236-106
    2.75 ERA
    1956 Ks
    1.215 WHIP
    Hall of Fame
    1x Cy Young
    10x All Star
    6x World Series
    1x WS MVP
    Starting PitcherC.C. Sabathia2009-2019134-88
    3.81 ERA
    1700 Ks
    1.272 WHIP
    3x All Star
    1x World Series
    Starting PitcherRon Guidry1975-1988170-91
    3.29 ERA
    1778 Ks
    1.184 WHIP
    1x Cy Young
    4x All Star
    2x World Series
    5x Gold Glove
    Starting PitcherLefty Gomez1930-1942198-101
    3.34 ERA
    1468 Ks
    1.351 WHIP
    Hall of Fame
    2x Triple Crown
    7x All Star
    5x World Series
    Relief PitcherMariano Rivera1995-201382-60
    2.21 ERA
    652 Saves
    1173 Ks
    Hall of Fame
    13x All Star
    5x World Series
    1x World Series MVP
    1x All Star MVP
    CatcherYogi Berra1946-1963.285 BA
    .348 OBP
    .483 SLG
    .830 OPS
    Hall of Fame
    3x MVP
    18x All Star
    10x World Series
    First BaseLou Gehrig1923-1939.340 BA
    .447 OBP
    .632 SLG
    1.080 OPS
    Hall of Fame
    2x MVP
    1x Triple Crown
    7x All Star
    6x World Series
    Second BaseRobinson Cano2005-2013.309 BA
    .355 OBP
    .504 SLG
    .860 OPS
    5x All Star
    1x World Series
    5x Silver Slugger
    1x Gold Glove
    Third BaseAlex Rodriguez2004-2013, 2015-2016.283 BA
    .378 OBP
    .523 SLG
    .900 OPS
    2x MVP
    7x All Star
    1x World Series
    3x Silver Slugger
    ShortstopDerek Jeter1995-2014.310 BA
    .377 OBP
    .440 SLG
    .817 OPS
    Hall of Fame
    14x All Star
    5x World Series
    Rookie of the Year
    5x Gold Glove
    5x Silver Slugger
    1x World Series MVP
    1x All Star MVP
    Left FieldJoe DiMaggio1936-1942, 1946-1951.325 BA
    .398 OBP
    .579 SLG
    .977 OPS
    Hall of Fame
    3x MVP
    13x All Star
    9x World Series
    Center FieldMickey Mantle1951-1968.298 BA
    .421 OBP
    .557 SLG
    .977 OPS
    Hall of Fame
    3x MVP
    1x Triple Crown
    20x All Star
    7x World Series
    1x Gold Glove
    Right FieldBabe Ruth1920-1934.349 BA
    .484 OBP
    .711 SLG
    1.195 OPS
    Hall of Fame
    1x MVP
    2x All Star
    7x World Series
    Util/DHRoger Maris1960-1966.265 BA
    .356 OBP
    .515 SLG
    .872 OPS
    2x MVP
    6x All Star
    3x World Series
    1x Gold Glove

    All-Time New York Yankees Lineup

    1. Mickey Mantle (Switch)
    2. Joe DiMaggio (Right)
    3. Babe Ruth (Left)
    4. Alex Rodriguez (Right)
    5. Lou Gehrig (Left)
    6. Derek Jeter (Right)
    7. Roger Maris (Left)
    8. Yogi Berra (Left)
    9. Robinson Cano (Left)

    Follow us on all of our social channels! Check out our Twitter, Facebook, YouTube and TikTok for more great FlurrySports content.


     

    MLB New York Yankees
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Previous ArticleCowboys Cornerback Targets in the 2021 NFL Draft
    Next Article Tua Tagovailoa Will Still Be the Best QB From the 2020 NFL Draft
    Luke Reimer
    • Facebook
    • X (Twitter)
    • Instagram

    From Green Bay, Wisconsin. NBA, College Basketball, MLB and NFL Fan/Writer. UW-La Crosse Graduate. Watch Sports, Play Basketball and Travel in Free Time. Love to go Fishing. Go Tar Heels.

    Related Posts

    March 30, 2025

    Best MLB Futures Wins Bets to Make For April 2025

    March 26, 2025

    1 Day Until Opening Day – Best Players to Wear 1 in MLB History

    March 25, 2025

    2 Days Until Opening Day – Best Players to Wear 2 in MLB History

    Add A Comment
    Leave A Reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

    Recently Published

    Early 2026 Dynasty Fantasy Football Rookie Rankings

    May 21, 2025

    NFL UDFAs Who Are Dynasty Fantasy Football Sleepers

    May 2, 2025

    Chris Eubank Jr vs. Conor Benn Purses, Salaries: How Much Money Will They Make at Tottenham?

    April 29, 2025

    Dynasty Fantasy Football Rookie Rankings 2025

    April 29, 2025
    Advertisements
    RSS FlurrySports Podcast
    • NFL Olympic Flag Football Draft (Ep. 219) May 27, 2025
    • Every 2000s Quarterback (Ep. 218) May 20, 2025
    • Doveland, Wisconsin (Ep. 217) May 13, 2025
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Advertise/Sponsor Opportunities
    You must be 21+ years old to wager. Bet within your means. If you have a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER |

    Copyright © 2017-2024 FlurrySports | Sitemap

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Ad Blocker Enabled!
    Ad Blocker Enabled!
    Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors. Please support us by disabling your Ad Blocker.